107 Comments

User's avatar
Dana Leigh Lyons's avatar

Note added June 8, 2025: After publishing this letter and seeing some of the comments come in, I realized I feel very uncomfortable inviting theories about what’s happening with any specific individual. Please feel free to share your thoughts about what The Machine might be—but let’s hold off, from here on out, on speculating about any specific person (whom none of us actually knows). I’m sorry. I’ll speak more to this in the follow-up post coming later this week. Thank you. ❤️

Expand full comment
Siobhán O'Connor's avatar

Yikes, my God that's scary. I'm sorry you are having to go through this.

You asked for theories!

To me, it sounds like the man has either psychosis or is stuck in some sort of trauma loop. There are accounts of people suffering in those ways that, rather than seek medical help, hide their condition (hence the denial) and get lost in pseudo cures that they make up for themselves (the thumping). Those rhythmic noises when applied in a clinical setting to a patient who is not suffering from psychosis, can be helpful. Think of tapping in EMDR trauma processing, for example. But if a psychotic person starts doing this on their own they can start believing the rhythms are the only thing keeping them alive, are a portal to other dimensions, are the sound of God healing them, and so on.

It's sad, but this sort of stuff goes on behind the closed doors of our neighbours more than we realise and, as you've seen, there's not much to be done about it. People who are sick like that are either going to let themselves be helped or not.

I worry for the mother, of course, but also theorise that she is probably there by choice, goes everywhere with him, enabling her son's illness and his hiding of it. As you might know, familial enablement is also common in things like addiction. There is shame around the illness. Family members will try to hide what they seen as an aberration, especially in certain cultures where psychosis is seen as evil/weakness.

You asked for a theory! My mind went into overdrive. Hope I haven't disturbed you more

Expand full comment
105 more comments...

No posts